PART 16Criminal Appeal RulesThese Rules are made by the Court of Appeal pursuant to section 482 of the Criminal Code, and are included with the civil rules for convenience. (continued)
DIVISION 4Scheduling Oral Argument
Marginal note:Scheduling conviction appeals
(2) A case management officer may at any time place any conviction appeal on the Unscheduled Criminal Appeals List.
(3) All the parties to each appeal on the Unscheduled Criminal Appeals List must appear at the time scheduled for the calling of the List, and
(4) If the appellant in an appeal referred to in subrule (3) does not appear at the time scheduled for the calling of the List, the appeal may be struck.
Section 672.72(3) of the Criminal Code provides that appeals from dispositions (after findings of not criminally responsible by reason of mental disorder) are to be expedited. Sections 51(1) and 57(5) of the Extradition Act require that appeals be heard at an early date.
The procedure for speaking to the Unscheduled Criminal Appeals List is set out in the Consolidated Practice Directions.
Marginal note:Unscheduled conviction appeals
16.21 If oral argument of a conviction appeal is not scheduled within 9 months of the filing of the notice of appeal, and no extension or direction has been received from a case management officer
(a) if the appellant is represented by counsel, the appeal will be struck by the Registrar, and
(b) if the appellant is a self-represented appellant, the Registrar will schedule the appeal for oral argument.
Marginal note:Scheduling sentence appeals
16.22 (1) Subject to the direction of a case management officer, 20 days before the opening day of each scheduled sitting for sentence appeals the Registrar will set down at that sitting every sentence appeal where
(a) the appeal record and appellant’s factum have been filed,
(b) the appeal record has been filed in a sentence appeal started by a self-represented appellant,
(c) the appeal record has not been ordered in a sentence appeal started by a self-represented appellant who is in custody, or
(d) the net sentence is 6 months or less, the appellant is in custody, and judicial interim release has not been granted.
(2) The Registrar must advise any self-represented party of the scheduled date of the sentence appeal.
(3) Unless otherwise ordered, the sentence appeal must proceed in accordance with the deadlines in this Part, notwithstanding that an appeal of the conviction appeal decision or an application for leave to appeal the conviction appeal decision has been filed with the Supreme Court of Canada.
Sentence appeals are heard every month in Edmonton and Calgary, except in July and August. Parties who wish to schedule matters (such as appeals of sentences of short duration) during the sittings in July should contact a case management officer for advice.
A case management officer can defer oral argument on sentence appeals where a self-represented party is awaiting confirmation of Legal Aid coverage, where a selfrepresented party intends to file a factum, or where other circumstances make the default scheduling rules inappropriate.
Marginal note:Bringing applications
(a) for an application to a single appeal judge, at least 10 days before the application is scheduled to be heard file 3 copies of an application and the other material required by subrule (2),
(b) for an application to a panel of the Court, at least 20 days before the application is scheduled to be heard file 5 copies of an application and the other material required by subrule (2), and
(c) within those same times, file and serve one additional copy of the application and other materials on every other party to the appeal.
(2) Subject to rule 16.24 [Application for permission to appeal], the applicant must file and serve
(a) an application in Form CRA-F that must
(b) any accompanying affidavit, if required,
(c) other material to be relied on, even if previously filed, and
(d) a memorandum of argument prepared in compliance with subrule 16.23(4).
(3) The respondent to an application
(a) to a single appeal judge must, at least 5 days before the application is scheduled to be heard, file
(b) to a panel of the Court must, at least 10 days before the application is scheduled to be heard, file
(i) 5 copies of a reply memorandum of argument and any accompanying affidavit (if required) and any other materials to be relied on, or
(ii) 5 copies of a letter indicating that no additional materials will be filed by the respondent,
(c) must within those same times, file and serve one additional copy of those materials on every other party to the appeal.
(4) Memoranda filed on an application must be formatted as required by rule 16.18(1)(a) and
(5) A respondent who fails to respond to an application or who elects not to file a memorandum in response to an application may not present oral argument at the hearing of the application unless the single appeal judge or the panel of the Court otherwise permits.
(6) Unless otherwise permitted,
(a) subject to paragraph (b), oral argument on an application, including a reply, before a single appeal judge or a panel of the Court may not exceed 15 minutes for each party to the application,
(b) oral argument on an application for permission to appeal, including a reply, may not exceed 30 minutes for each party to the application, and
(c) consolidated applications are to be treated as one application for the purpose of this rule.
All of the materials should be filed simultaneously, unless the application must be filed first to preserve a time limit. If in urgent matters the applicant wishes to abridge the time limits, a case management officer should be consulted for directions.
Marginal note:Application for permission to appeal
(2) Subject to any enactment, no appeal lies from an order of a single appeal judge granting or denying permission to appeal.
(3) An application for permission to appeal that has not been heard within 6 months from the date of the filing of the application is deemed to have been abandoned unless a case management officer otherwise directs.
- Date modified: